I Want A World Without War

Originally posted in May, 2011… revised and reposted Memorial Day Weekend 2012.

My heart hurts whenever I hear or think about all the pain and loss war causes. I respect and honor the individuals who serve in the armed services, especially the ones who have lost their lives and my heart breaks for their loved ones.

I cannot imagine how either the soldiers and their loved ones at home handle the long deployments, that are filled with too many unknowns. I am sadden for the way that everyone who comes home from a war will have a body, mind and spirit that will be affected for the rest of their life… some more severe than others.

I want a world without war.

'✌ peace ✌ mšvidoba ✌ мир ✌ שָׁלוֹם ✌ سلا' photo (c) 2006, ion-bogdan dumitrescu - license: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/

I dream of giving birth to a child who will ask,
“Mother, what was war?
- Eve Merriam

We teach our children to solve their problems with words, not with fighting. Why can’t adults do the same? Yes, I know there are numerous barriers to a world without war … enemies, evil dictators, power-hungry leaders and more.

Without war … I don’t know how the situation with Hitler should have been handled. I don’t know the best way a country should respond to terrorist attacks. I can hardly allow myself to think about the many (millions?) around the world who are controlled daily by a dictator.

But does war really solve more issues than it creates?

A great war leaves the country with three armies
- an army of cripples, an army of mourners,
and an army of thieves.
~ German Proverb

My sons have wondered if I am only a pacifist due to my Traditional Mennonite upbringing. Traditional Mennonite churches encourage nonresistance lifestyles and forbid any of their members to serve in the armed services or even as a police officer. So while that influences me, that is not why I am a pacifist today.

After leaving the Mennonite world in my early twenties, there was about a decade when I didn’t identify myself as a pacifist. Adjusting to life outside the boxes of my childhood (where rules and doctrines had controlled my beliefs) meant I needed to examine many aspects of life to determine what I personally believe… instead of simply believing what others say I should.

Since I wasn’t used to standing on my own two feet concerning my beliefs, for a time, I decided that war must be a necessary evil because I allowed my beliefs to be influenced by the conservative evangelical culture I was a part of then. I find it interesting that every act of terror or war that America or Israel did/does is called a “just war“ but acts of terror or wars by others are not. (but that’s a post for another day)

After the invasion of Afghanistan (’01) and Iraq (’03), I began questioning the value of war. Then I went through the trauma of the accident (’04) I lived with severe pain for years and still live with some pain today. I struggled with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and still have flashes of it. So I revisited my thoughts and beliefs on war. I’m no expert, but I did what I could to study the effects of war on individuals and on countries.

I cannot be anything other than a pacifist.

When people hear that I’m a pacifist, one question I’m often asked is how would I react if my life or someone else’s life was threaten. Some of you will see this as a contradiction (sometimes I even do) but I would respond in self-defense. Recently I even took a personal self-defense class so I know what to do if I find myself in a dangerous situation. That may or may not be the right thing to do. But that seems different than one country going to war with another country.

You can no more win a war than
you can win an earthquake
. ~ Jeanette Rankin

Post-war devastation is brutal for everyone involved. Do you realize how much good all the money spent on war could accomplish? Food, shelter, education for everyone in this country and many more!

Yes, my heart breaks for the people who lost loved ones on 9/11 … and in other acts of terror around the world. And my heart breaks for the civilians who are killed during wars … too many times from bombs dropped by America.

I hope the distant day John F. Kennedy talked about arrives soon:

War will exist until that distant day when
the conscientious objector enjoys the same reputation
and prestige that the warrior does today.
This weekend I will remember the people who have sacrificed in wars past, people who are serving today and soldiers who are coming home only to be traumatized with injuries and/or PTSD for the rest of their lives.

And I will also think and dream about a world without war.

.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://www.pilgrimsmoon.com Tess Giles Marshall

    All these questions you set out are the right ones, and there are certainly no easy answers. I know I have it in me to kill in self-defence. What makes my blood run cold are the expressions that have arisen to hide bloody death and war. “Collateral damage”, “conflict”. Horrendous.

    • http://www.JanetOberholtzer.com Janet Oberholtzer

      Agree with you Tess … that language bothers me also. It’s people that are getting hurt or killed!

  • http://kclanderson.com KCLAnderson (Karen)

    Excellent post Janet. I used to think it was just too overwhelming to try and do anything that could possibly make a difference, but I have come to realize that world peace does indeed start with me. I wrote a post about it a while back and just resurrected (and edited) it yesterday.

    • http://www.JanetOberholtzer.com Janet Oberholtzer

      It does feel overwhelming Karen … even writing this, I wondered if I should publish it because I can say I’m a pacifist, but what am I doing to live it? Your post is a great reminder that it does begin with accepting and loving ourselves.
      And to my readers … go read Karen’s post, it’s excellent: http://www.kclanderson.com/the-world-peace-diet-2

  • Patrick Leaman

    Nice post, Janet.  I struggle with this too.  I have 3 kids ages 7 and under and feel I have to give them an understanding of memorial day different than the cliche’s on TV.  I am at a place (and always have been) where I can endorse those that give their life for peace.  Like my friend Glen Lapp who died in Afghanistan last year.  He knew the risks going there, but went anyway… unarmed.  http://articles.philly.com/2010-08-09/news/24970989_1_aid-group-medical-volunteers-medical-aid However, I am inching towards a place where I can endorse those who leave here carrying weapons, to fight on foreign turf.  This is very much a departure from what I was taught.  However, there are those who wish to do us harm and these people choose to risk their life to protect us. 

    For me, today, I hold Glen up with all the others our country is acknowledging the service of.

    • http://www.JanetOberholtzer.com Janet Oberholtzer

      It’s an issue we all have to grapple with for ourselves and there’s a certain tension in whatever side we land on. 
      Living in the Lancaster area, I had heard about Glen’s story … and as I googled something about Mennonite pacifists for this article, the stories about Glen came up. Remembering the service Glen (and others like him) did on Memorial Day is a good thing.

  • Jim Messner

    Janet, My wife and I were at ENCORE: The Festival and heard your presentation. When you mentioned cutting all ties to a place and getting in an RV, it was my wife that cheered.  We had two wonderful years as full time RVers. But we were keenly aware that we traveled with all of our worldly goods.

    Back in 1966, I registered with The Draft Board as a conscientious objector (Non-Military). Then my Methodist pastor said that if I was truly unafraid of dying in the military zone, that I should change my status to C.O.  military. In I was a few weeks I was in the army. After basic training I was sent to Fort Sam Huston, to be trained as a medic (the only thing that the military saw as a job description for a C.O.  I sought guidance from a Methodist pastor in San Antonio and he didn’t help. Then I found a contact with the Mennonite Central Committee and I discovered an organization that was steeped in the pacifist tradition. God bless the Mennonites !